Question : Data Validation with Dynamic Named Range

Hi guys,

This one is driving me nuts.  I have two sheets with named ranges (each are entire columns).  I'm using data validation to set these to dynamic ranges (removing the header in each column).

This works:
=OFFSET(INDIRECT(PCType1),1,0,COUNTA(INDIRECT(PCType1))-1,1)

This doesn't work:
=OFFSET(INDIRECT(InvalidNames),1,0,COUNTA(INDIRECT(InvalidNames))-1,1)

Both are named ranges set to Column D in each of the sheets.  Does anyone know what's causing this?  I've attached a sample workbook which shows it working in one sheet and not working in the other sheet.

Attachments:

Sample.xls (33 KB)  (File Type Details) 

Sample

Answer : Data Validation with Dynamic Named Range

See attached.

Kevin