The problem was resolved for Jon by moving his mailbox. I'm thinking the move cleaned some sort of corrupt messsage or meta file up in the mailbox. I'll be moving another user over night that i believe has the same issue. Jon had already cleaned his mailbox up. The nmumber of items was at a good level.
alanhardisty,
I looked through your post. thank you, iot's very comprehensive. there are descrepencies with it and my config, but it is working.