I am not 100% for certain on this model of printer, but I know on some other makes/models the toner cartdridge has a small chip at one end. This is read by the machine and has a memory. Unless the physical cartdridge is replaced, you will get this symptom. I am not for sure exactly how the chip works, if it has a meter count it keeps track of or if it uses a serial number and once the light comes on it will not reset until it detects a different serial number.