LSI by far, as not only do HP, IBM, Sun, NetApp, Dell, Supermicro, SGI, and more slap their names on LSI controllers, but the LSI chipsets provide the back-end expanders and chipsets for the RAID vendors. goto lsi.com, look at the controllers and select one that meets your budget. I would go with a BBU as well, as this provides additional performance/availability benefits, especially in a degraded mode. Also look at the SAS-2 versions that give 6Gbit/second paths. Go with the newer Seagate SAS-2 disks as well. Also SAS has independent read and write channels, so you can get the disks to do a lot more work before saturating things, you also get a nice upgrade path and can support more drives.