Try the good old tedious troubleshooting method. Open msconfig and disable all startup items and see if the button works. If the button works then try enabling each startup items. I would disable non-microsoft services as well. You said a couple of xp users but you didn't say whether it was on the same xp machine or different xp machines. If this was in multiple machines, I would guess that you install some kind of application or windows update on all of these machines. I would uninstall those updates/apps and try then.